This book was an enjoyable read and I loved the Scottish island the story is set on. There were characters you got to know well and loved, and the sense of community was very heart-warming. The two main characters - Kyla and Evanna - were also loveable, if a bit dim at times and too easily controlled by their feelings for the men in the stories. The only thing that I didn't like was the fact that the book was split into two separate stories for these two characters. I felt it would have flowed better had the two storylines run alongside each other. Also, the title of the book doesn't reflect the stories at all or do the book justice! But other than that, I really enjoyed it. I give this book 8/10.